I consider the following Pennsylvania Railroad model railroads to have a high degree of fidelity to the prototype. They are not freelance, protolance, etc., but depict specific locales on the Pennsy based on historic documentation with a minimum of "modeler's license."

Those in bold I have had the opportunity to operate on. Those in italics are on my "bucket list" to visit.

 

 

Eastern Region

Maryland Division

Main Line at Baltimore and Northern Central Branch to xxx

Ken Myer
Bel Air MD
    meyer

Main Line Baltimore to Wilmington

Don Richard
WIlmington DE
1967 

FaceBook 

Bill Fagan Flyover Video

33141805 10216782534705041 1846090232173166592 n

Philadelphia Terminal Division

30th Street Station, Zoo

Charles Chandler II   Model Railroad Open House FaceBook  23915835 1930394650308130 1448500818339103421 n

Chestnut Hill Branch,
Stifftown Branch

Ron Hoess

  Bill Fagan Flyover Video  Hoess1

Canal Street Branch

Ron Klais    FaceBook 18767642 1435054549889609 5332160248128994142 n

North Philadelphia,
Frankford Junction

Peter Forbes     Pete Forbes v15

New York Division

Elizabeth to Newark

Andy Rubbo  

Great Model Railroads 2013

Model Railroad Hobbyist, Nov 2016

6ad4d61890db198aa940e6badc402c7d 

Philadelphia Division

Cumberland Valley Branch

Jim Clay (deceased)
Camp Hill PA
     

Middle Division

Main Line at Denholm

Railroad Museum of Pennsylvania
Strasburg PA
   Web Site 200510111104 HO Darrow Denholm 6 

Main Line at Lewistown, Lewistown Secondary,
Milroy Secondary

Jerry Britton
Etters PA
1950s

Web Site 

FaceBook

 

Altoona to Gallitzin

Dave Johnson 1952  Web Site LayoutAtAGlance

Main Line Spruce Creek to Tunnel Hill

Ken Rideout
Philadelphia PA
  Video   

Central Region

Pittsburgh Division

Altoona to Gallitzin Dave Johnson 1952  Web Site LayoutAtAGlance
Main Line Spruce Creek to Tunnel Hill Ken Rideout
Philadelphia PA
  Video   

Main Line Harrisburg to Buffalo

Ken McCorry
Downingtown PA
 

Philadelphia NMRA Web Site

Bill Fagan Flyover Video 

Model Railroader
Dec 2004

p9260134 1002x750

Susquehanna Division

Main Line Harrisburg to Buffalo Ken McCorry
Downingtown PA
 

Philadelphia NMRA Web Site

Bill Fagan Flyover Video 

Model Railroader
Dec 2004

p9260134 1002x750
Shamokin Branch Chuck Cover 1957    

Shamokin Branch

Lower Anthracite Model Railroad Club
Shamoken PA
  FaceBook loweranthracite

Main Line Williamsport to Buffalo

Steven Mallery
Camp Hill PA
1960's

Web Site

Philadelphia NMRA Web Site

Bill Fagan Main Line Cab Ride Video

mallery

Elmira Branch and Sodus Point Branch

Anthony Daniele
Long Island NY
1956 Great Model Railroads 2020 daniele plan

Panhandle Division

Burgettstown, Pa
to Steubenville, Oh
Curt LaRue
OH
1950s  Great Model Railroads 2011 LaRue
Weirton Junction
and Mingo Junction
Bill Neale
Northville MI
1939 

NMRA Motor City Division Web Site

Video

Great Model Railroads 2010

neale plan

Other Lines

New York & Long Branch Railroad Jerry Wooley
Point Pleasant NJ
  Web Site